While it's easy to predict a Hamilton sweep at the 2016 Tony Awards (it racked up a record-breaking 16 nominations), it's less obvious who will win this year's red carpet. After all, with fashion superstars like Lupita Nyong'o and Michelle Williams in attendance, just who everyone will be talking about the next morning is anyone's guess. Plus, there's always the chance for a pleasant surprise—remember last year when none other than Jennifer Lopez showed up at nearly the last minute in a stunning navy strapless Valentino Couture gown with gold star-shaped sequins?