Handy or Anley was the name of the romantic relationship between Haley Dunphy and Andy Bailey. It is currently the most popular ship with fans of the series. As of right now, Haley and Andy are broken up because Andy had to move back to Utah to pursue his dream career as a real estate agent. Haley told Andy he is the first man she ever loved ("Double Click"). Beth - Beth, Andy's girlfriend and later fiancee, was the reason Andy left in "The Wedding (Part Two)" and what prevented Haley and Andy f